Best Sticky Toffee Pudding in Edinburgh

Sticky Toffee Pudding is an insanely rich, moist sponge cake made with finely chopped dates, covered in a warm toffee sauce, and often served with vanilla ice cream or custard. While its exact origin is debated, it is a beloved staple in Scottish pubs and restaurants. Order it **"With Extra Sauce"**. The trap is a "microwaved" pudding that is dry in the middle; a real sticky toffee pudding should be almost dripping with dark, buttery sauce. Expect to pay £7–£11.

Sticky Toffee Pudding · say “Sticky Toffee Pudding” ·

How this ranking works

Guide score ✕ verified reader stamps ✕ critic notes. External reviews are linked, never copied.

What to order

·

Why locals care

Sticky Toffee Pudding is an insanely rich, moist sponge cake made with finely chopped dates, covered in a warm toffee sauce, and often served with vanilla ice cream or custard. While its exact origin is debated, it is a beloved staple in Scottish pubs and restaurants. Order it **"With Extra Sauce"**. The trap is a "microwaved" pudding that is dry in the middle; a real sticky toffee pudding should be almost dripping with dark, buttery sauce. Expect to pay £7–£11.

The ranking · 20 stops

Where to eat Sticky Toffee Pudding

10.0/ 10

Bennets Bar

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A historic pub with original Victorian features; their sticky toffee pudding is a favorite for regular patrons.Tollcross
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
20.0/ 10

Diggers

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A legendary local institution where the sticky toffee pudding is as hearty and unpretentious as the pub itself.Haymarket
Queue
Go
Price
$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
30.0/ 10

Hawksmoor Edinburgh

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
While a steakhouse, their sticky toffee pudding is frequently cited as one of the best in the UK.New Town
Queue
Go
Price
$$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
40.0/ 10

Guildford Arms

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
An ornate, historic pub where the sticky toffee pudding is served with traditional Scottish custard.East End
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
50.0/ 10

Cumberland Bar

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A beautiful neighborhood pub where the sticky toffee pudding is a favorite for family Sunday roasts.New Town
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
60.0/ 10

Starbank Inn

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A beautiful waterfront pub; their sticky toffee pudding is famous among locals for its generous portions.Newhaven
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
70.0/ 10

The Magnum

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
Their sticky toffee pudding is refined, perfectly balanced, and served with high-end vanilla bean ice cream.New Town
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
80.0/ 10

Whiski Rooms

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
Their sticky toffee pudding is a signature dessert, often recommended to be paired with a smoky Islay whisky.Old Town
Queue
Go
Price
$$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
90.0/ 10

The Last Drop

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A historic pub in the heart of the Grassmarket; their sticky toffee pudding is a classic Edinburgh comfort dish.Grassmarket
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
100.0/ 10

Dagda Bar

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A tiny, atmospheric pub that serves a very high-quality sticky toffee pudding from a local artisanal baker.Southside
Queue
Go
Price
$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
110.0/ 10

Cafe Royal

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
Their sticky toffee pudding is a sophisticated and very popular dessert, especially during the winter months.East End
Queue
Go
Price
$$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
120.0/ 10

Kay's Bar

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
Tucked away on a quiet street; their sticky toffee pudding is known for its particularly rich and buttery sauce.New Town
Queue
Go
Price
$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
130.0/ 10

The Blue Blazer

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A favorite among locals; their sticky toffee pudding is simple, honest, and the perfect finish to a pub lunch.Old Town
Queue
Go
Price
$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
140.0/ 10

Howies

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A reliable spot for a high-quality, seasonal sticky toffee pudding that uses the best Scottish butter and cream.various
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
150.0/ 10

The Malt Shovel

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A classic real ale pub where the sticky toffee pudding is a staple of the traditional bar food menu.New Town
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
160.0/ 10

Arcade Bar, Haggis & Whisky House

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
Known for its incredible comfort food; the sticky toffee pudding is the perfect finish to a Scottish feast.Old Town
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
170.0/ 10

George IV Bar

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A classic pub where the sticky toffee pudding is known for its incredibly rich, dark sauce and moist sponge.Old Town
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
180.0/ 10

The Doric

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A classic gastropub; their sticky toffee pudding is rustic, hearty, and very traditional.Old Town
Queue
Go
Price
$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
190.0/ 10

Wedgwood the Restaurant

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
Their "very sticky" toffee pudding is a legendary dessert in the city's food scene.Old Town
Queue
Go
20:00 (Dinner).
Price
$$$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps
200.0/ 10

Cloisters Bar

0 stamped

Order:

Verdict
A real ale pub that often has a very authentic and affordable sticky toffee pudding on its daily specials board.Tolcross
Queue
Go
Price
$
Dietary
Stamp availableGoogle Maps

Decide at a glance

Worth a meal slot?

Top score

0.0 / 10

Verified venues

20 stops

Per meal

Heads up

None known

Smaller context

Food near POIs

Palace of Holyroodhouse

Palace of Holyroodhouse

Best nearby foods: Signature order

Pairs naturally with this food stop.

Challenges live in the app

Collect the dish stamp, submit proof, and earn XP from the mobile app after you choose a stop.

Have a dietary preference? We will surface relevant reports first.

Be the first to post a queue update or order tip in f/sticky-toffee-pudding.

Is the queue moving fast right now?